Four Seasons vs. Rosewood: Luxury Caribbean Resorts – Which Is Right for You?

Choosing between luxury Caribbean resorts like Four Seasons Anguilla and Rosewood Little Dix Bay is a true luxury dilemma. Both are exquisite in design, service, and setting—yet they cater to slightly different vibes and travel styles. Here’s a deep dive to help you make your choice.

🏖️ Four Seasons Anguilla

Located on the serene shores of Barnes and Meads Bay, Four Seasons Anguilla delivers sleek modern luxury with dramatic ocean views. Think marble bathrooms, plunge pools, rooftop lounges, and a spa that overlooks the sea. It’s a great choice for families thanks to the complimentary kids’ program and spacious villas with kitchens. Active travelers will love the rock climbing wall, water sports center, and tennis courts on-site.

The resort’s design feels polished and architectural, ideal for those who appreciate understated opulence. Dining options range from toes-in-the-sand beach bars to fine-dining restaurants with menus curated by renowned chefs. With direct flights into Anguilla or nearby St. Maarten followed by a ferry transfer, it’s easily accessible but feels worlds away.

For couples, the resort offers sunset yoga, beachfront fire pits, and private dinners. And for those seeking wellness, there’s a full slate of spa services and fitness programs including Pilates, guided meditation, and tennis clinics with pros.

🌿 Rosewood Little Dix Bay

Rosewood Little Dix Bay in Virgin Gorda is an eco-luxury resort that blends barefoot elegance with Caribbean heritage. Nestled in a protected bay, its open-air suites and villas feature hand-carved furniture and local stone accents. The vibe is laid-back and romantic, perfect for couples and honeymooners looking to disconnect.

Guests can enjoy yoga pavilions, nature trails, a holistic spa, and boat trips to secluded beaches. Dining emphasizes locally sourced ingredients and Caribbean flavors. While kids are welcome, this property leans more adults-only in feel. Accessibility is via flights into Tortola or St. Thomas followed by a short ferry ride, making it ideal for travelers who value seclusion.

The Rosewood Little Dix Bay offers cultural touches like Caribbean cooking classes, garden-to-table tours, and rum tastings under the stars. For outdoor lovers, the nearby Gorda Peak National Park and The Baths offer unforgettable day trips full of hiking and exploration.

🌅 Bonus Pick: Jumby Bay Island, Antigua

For a private-island escape, Jumby Bay Island in Antigua offers all-inclusive luxury with a castaway twist. Accessible only by boat, this resort feels like a secluded paradise with white sand beaches, palm trees, and world-class service. Each villa or estate home is uniquely designed and comes with a personal butler.

Guests enjoy gourmet dining, complimentary water sports, sunset cruises, and a serene beachfront spa. Jumby Bay is ideal for travelers seeking exclusivity, quiet elegance, and top-tier hospitality. Though it comes at a premium, the attention to detail and intimacy make it worth the investment for special occasions or once-in-a-lifetime escapes.

Pro tip: Jumby Bay Island’s all-inclusive rate covers nearly everything—food, alcohol, activities—making it one of the most complete luxury experiences in the Caribbean. For honeymooners or milestone trips, this is a resort that truly pampers.

📓 Which Is Right for You?

• Go Four Seasons if you want slick modern amenities, a vibrant atmosphere, and family-friendly touches.
• Choose Rosewood for barefoot luxury, eco-conscious design, and romance-driven tranquility.
• Pick Jumby Bay if you want private-island seclusion and an all-inclusive luxury experience with every detail handled.

All three resorts belong to the elite echelon of luxury Caribbean resorts and could easily be called the best resort Caribbean luxury. Whether you’re drawn to the most luxurious Caribbean resorts for peace, prestige, or pampering, these top luxury Caribbean resorts each promise a bespoke island experience like no other.

🌐 Travel Planning Tip

This post may contain affiliate links. If you buy through them, I may earn a small commission — at no extra cost to you. This has been a blog post about Luxury Caribbean Resorts.